open-design/specs
Nagendhra Madishetti 47eeaf445d
feat: Critique Theater foundation (contracts + parser, Phases 0-2) (#387)
* docs(specs): add Critique Theater design spec for panel-tempered artifacts

* docs(specs): add Critique Theater implementation plan

* docs(specs): rename UI to Design Jury, add lane-density modes, ship-rule explainer, label sizing

* feat(contracts): add CritiqueConfig schema and defaults

* fix(contracts): apply Task 1.1 review (CRITIQUE_PROTOCOL_VERSION rename, descriptions, RoleWeights export)

* feat(contracts): add PanelEvent discriminated union and isPanelEvent guard

* fix(contracts): apply Task 1.2 review (exhaustive event-type list, runId guard, import order)

* feat(contracts): add CritiqueSseEvent variants and panelEventToSse mapper

* test(daemon): add v1 wire-protocol golden fixtures for Critique Theater parser

* feat(daemon): add v1 streaming parser for Critique Theater wire protocol

* chore(contracts): add .js extensions to relative imports for NodeNext consumers

* fix(daemon): satisfy noUncheckedIndexedAccess in v1 parser regex match access

* test(daemon): cover parser failure modes; fix unclosed-PANELIST swallow bug

* fix(daemon,contracts): address PR #387 review

- parser now clamps panelist + DIM scores against the run-declared scale
  captured from <CRITIQUE_RUN scale=...>, not a hardcoded 100
- PANELIST appearing before any <ROUND n=...> opens now throws
  MalformedBlockError rather than emitting events with NaN round
- DIM_RE and MUST_FIX_RE hoisted to module scope and lastIndex reset per
  call so the parser hot path stops recompiling regex per artifact
- overflow check after drain simplified to a plain buf.length > cap test
  (the prior compound condition was always true on the right side and
  obscured intent)
- scoreThreshold <= scoreScale refine gains a 1e-9 epsilon so floating
  slack does not reject semantically valid configs
- round-1 designer ARTIFACT guard gains a comment naming the spec
  invariant and the v2 relaxation path
- 3 new regression tests cover the panelist-without-round, scale=10
  clamp, and scale=20 plumbing cases

* docs(specs): rationale for non-goals, failure-mode rate targets, Phase 10 matrix, Phase 14 doc layout

* Merge branch 'main' into feat/critique-theater

Resolves the contracts/index.ts conflict by keeping the .js extensions added
by chore(contracts) 2d6e8d6 and slotting in the new export for ./api/app-config
introduced upstream by #255 (9d700ec). Critique Theater additions
(./sse/critique, ./critique) preserved in their original positions.

Verified after merge:
  pnpm --filter @open-design/contracts test    -> 10/10 pass
  pnpm --filter @open-design/contracts typecheck -> exit 0
  pnpm --filter @open-design/daemon typecheck  -> exit 0
  pnpm --filter @open-design/web typecheck     -> exit 0

Two daemon tests in tests/media-config.test.ts fail both before and after the
merge because they read real OAuth credentials from the developer machine
instead of using mock fixtures. That's an upstream isolation issue on
origin/main, not something this branch introduces.

* fix: unblock web build and address mrcfps PANELIST oversize bypass

The chore commit that added .js extensions to satisfy daemon's nodenext
typecheck broke apps/web's Next.js build, because webpack tried to resolve
the literal ./common.js when only common.ts exists on disk. Replaced with
a subpath approach: contracts/exports gains a './critique' entry pointing
straight at src/critique.ts (which has no relative imports), and daemon
imports route through @open-design/contracts/critique instead of the
barrel. Web keeps the bundler-friendly barrel; daemon's nodenext walks
only the leaf module. All 13 contracts source files reverted to no-.js.

Separately, mrcfps flagged that parserMaxBlockBytes was only enforced on
the leftover buffer after drain returned, so a complete oversized block
arriving in one chunk slipped past the cap. Added an explicit per-block
size check inside drain for every buffered block type (PANELIST,
ROUND_END, SHIP). Three regression tests yield the whole stream as a
single chunk and assert OversizeBlockError fires before any events emit.

* fix(daemon): close three v1 parser invariant gaps from mrcfps review

Three independent gaps that all let malformed or oversized protocol
output pass the v1 envelope contract:

(1) Envelope guard. ROUND, PANELIST, ROUND_END, and SHIP now throw
MalformedBlockError when state.inRun is false. Without this, a stream
that omits <CRITIQUE_RUN> could still emit panelist_* events without
the run_started handshake, leaving downstream reducers with no run-level
config.

(2) UTF-8 byte length. Both the per-block size check and the post-drain
buf-size check now compare Buffer.byteLength(text, 'utf8') against
parserMaxBlockBytes. The previous string-length comparison let multibyte
content (CJK, emoji) inside <NOTES>/<SUMMARY> exceed the configured
byte cap while staying under the JS string length cap, bypassing the
daemon's resource guard.

(3) Header-end ordering. PANELIST, ROUND_END, and SHIP now require the
opener's > to appear before the matched closing tag. A malformed opener
like <PANELIST role="x" score="8"</PANELIST> previously fell through
to the closing tag's > and emitted events for an invalid block.

Four regression tests cover each gap (ROUND-without-run,
SHIP-without-run, multibyte-byte-cap, malformed-opener).

* fix(lockfile): regenerate to include contracts zod + vitest entries

The earlier conflict resolution took main's lockfile and ran pnpm
install, but the install pass on Windows didn't write the contracts
package's zod and vitest entries back into the lockfile. CI's
--frozen-lockfile install rejected the resulting state. Re-running
pnpm install with --no-frozen-lockfile rewrites the lockfile so it
now matches every package.json across the workspace, including
contracts/zod ^3.23.8 and contracts/vitest ^2.1.8. Verified locally:
pnpm install --frozen-lockfile passes.

---------

Co-authored-by: Nagendhra <nagendhra405@gmail.com>
2026-05-04 20:28:28 +08:00
..
change/20260430-implement-maintainability-w2-w3 Refresh desktop integration control plane (#123) 2026-04-30 14:23:53 +08:00
current feat: Critique Theater foundation (contracts + parser, Phases 0-2) (#387) 2026-05-04 20:28:28 +08:00